Tags
Delmore Schwartz, echo, Fred Chappell, ghazal, Narcissus, Pablo Neruda, Pura López-Colomé, refrain
It’s Spring in the Northern Hemisphere, bringing to life all those bulbs that have loitered through the cold and dark of our winter. Most iconic are the daffodils – or to be be generically precise, Narcissi. Which calls to mind the myth of that handsome youth by a stream so caught up by his own reflection that he cannot relate to all those mesmerised by his beauty. Delmore Schwartz’s “Narcissus” poem paints a more sympathetic picture though:
“…did they suppose
Self-love was unrequited, or betrayed?
They thought I had fallen in love with my own face,
And this belief became the night-like obstacle
To understanding all my unbroken suffering,
My studious self-regard, the pain of hope,
The torment of possibility:
How then could I have expected them to see me
As I saw myself, within my gaze, or see
That being thus seemed as a toad, a frog, a wren, a mole.
Knowing their certainty that I was only
A monument, a monster who had fallen in love
With himself alone, how could I have
Told them what was in me, within my heart, trembling and passionate
…Do you hear, do you see? Do you understand me now, and how
The words for what is my heart do not exist…?
The nymph, Echo was just one of his admirers but, having already been cursed to only reiterate the last of another’s speech, is doubly cursed with unrequited love and the powerlessness of self expression. The myth is beautifully rendered in this translation of Pura López-Colomé’s “Echo”
“…I’m caught in the bubble
of your breath.
It locks me in.
Drives me mad.Confined to speak alone,
I talk and listen,
ask questions and answer myself.
I hum, I think I sing,
I breathe in, breathe in and don’t explode.
I’m no one…”
And here we have the pair monologuing together in this repeat echoing poem by Fred Chappell:-

And so for today’s Meeting the Bar prompt we are writing a poem that includes questions, answers and repeat lines (refrains).
Poetry Prompt: Include AT LEAST ONE of these in your poem, from Pablo Neruda’s ‘Book of Questions’. [suggestion – regard these as rhetorical, i.e. self-reflective]. I like to use as an opening epigraph with nod to the author of course
• Why was I not born mysterious?
• Why did I grow up without companions?
• Do unshed tears wait in little lakes?
• How long do others speak if we have already spoken?
• Why does Spring once again offer its green clothes?
• Isn’t it better never than late?
Poetry Style:
• Write your poem as a Ghazal*
• 5 -15 rhyming couplets
• AA, BA, CA, DA, EA, etc
OR
• As free verse, with each line ending in a separate echoing word, as in Chappell’s poem above
[suggestion – you could write it as two columns or with caesura]
Poetry Theme:
any of your choosing though you may want to focus on Spring or the Narcissus/Echo myth or any such love story, since Ghazal’s traditionally deal with loss and romantic love.
Information Links:
*All about the Ghazal
*Examples of Ghazal poems
The Ghazal is one we have met several times here on dVerse ( just search it) including a good explanation of origins with examples HERE
So once you have posted your poem according to the guidelines above, do add it to Mr Linky below then go visiting and reading other contributors as that is half the fun of our dVerse gatherings.
[N.B. Mr Linky closes Saturday 3 p.m. EST]
Hello! Helloo! Is there an echo in here?! (There is a reason I’m a writer, not a comedian.🥁)
Welcome to Meeting the Bar! I am filling in for lovely Laura. She’s crafted us a great prompt. Special tonight we have the Ghazal, which is 5 parts gin, 1 part freshly squeezed lime juice, 1/2 part rose water, and a sprig of mint leaves. I will get you a drink and a snack, listen to your woes, and read your echoes. Let’s write!
nearly midnight here Melissa and about to have a bedtime hot choc but thank you for being barista and host - will try and catch up tomorrow x
Any time!☺️
Hello, I will need to ponder this prompt and get back tomorrow… I was out with friends tonight, and need to sleep on this first.
I am not done writing mine yet. What time is it there? Hopefully you’ll hear some echoes in your dreams.😴
It’s 9PM already
hello poets and special thanks to Melissa for hosting here - I’ll be able to pop in every now and then tomorrow to read your poems as am holidaying with family in Israel so out and about and busy most of the time. I hope the prompt inspires
I have no idea if my entry is in correct form, Laura, but submit it anyway. Thanks
I believe you combined both options for prompts into one.
Thank you Laura and Melissa. I do like ghazals, but I haven’t written one in a while. I’ll see if I have a chance to respond tomorrow.
Hi Merril!🤗 Still writing mine. This is a challenging prompt.
It is!
A challenging prompt, Laura. Thank you for hosting. I am giving it a try. Not sure if I got the echo, but I was inspired to write a ghazal, so I hope it is acceptable.
This is a seriously meaty prompt, to end a dense day, I think I need something light to inspire words to bubble and play while I stare into the mirror behind the bar.
I see you’ve posted in Mr. Linky, so I hope you grabbed yourself a drink. Here’s some champagne just in case.🥂
I gave it a go!
Hello, Laura and Melissa, thanks for hosting, I’ve tried to give the prompt some justice and I enjoyed the process.
Hello, Jay! Happy to see you here.🤗
Full of doubt I started and full of doubt I ended. It’s a spectacular prompt, Laura, I didn’t think (don’t think) I have the chops for… anyway, I posted my link. Let the naysayers naysay–I will learn from it. Thank you for giving me this chance. Bless you.
the link: https://selmamartin.com/24-contemplation-better-late-than-never-or-better-never-than-late/
And thanks so much, Melissa.
And that drink sounds delicious. May I please… xo
To drown down my doubts.
Sure, Selma! One Ghazal for you. Enjoy! Heading over to read yours now.🥰
Better late than never— I wrote a poem trying a little bit of this and that from the prompt.
Thanks Laura and Melissa. Laura, when I found the photos on my post in a folder on my computer, I immediately thought of you. (K)
Thank you Laura and Melissa for hosting. Wow! This prompt was difficult and I hope I did it justice. 🙂
Greetings Poets! A complex challenge, hoping I can rise high!
Every prompt is a learning opportunity for me. Did a lot of readings for this one though I’m still not sure I understood and executed them correctly 😅. Constructive criticism is sought, please ☺️.
Enjoyed reading the other poems 💞. Thank you.
The Ghazal form is challenging but I was pleased to try it – not exactly a love song though as originally conceived, thank you Laura and Melissa…
There is a review of a new illustrated edition of Pablo Neruda’s Book of Questions – illustrated beautifully by a friend of his – reviewed in the amazing blog The Marginalia…
Thank you for hosting Laura. I took a fine old free verse poem of mine, and made it echo… echo — hope so… 🤞🏼🙏🏽🤔
Such beautiful poetry. ❤️