Tags
Looking out the window, Mary Jean Chan, National Poetry Competition, Once in a lifetime, The Poetry Society
It’s Tuesday and the dVerse Poets Pub is open with cold drinks, a range of salads, and any ice cream of your choice, as well as a selection of delicious poetry. I’m Kim from writinginnorthnorfolk.com, your host for this week’s Poetics.
I used to be a member of The Poetry Society (UK) and entered the National Poetry Competition many times. I still follow the competition and receive various communications from The Poetry Society. Over the years I have also collected their prompts.
This week’s Poetics is based on one of those prompts and a poem that came second in the National Poetry Competition in 2017. Read the poem ‘The Window’ by Mary Jean Chan here.

This poem begins with a somewhat grand statement:
“Once in a lifetime , you will gesture at an open window…”
It presents the reader with an open window, but we see beyond the window into the poet’s life, in which she is struggling with her mother’s reaction to her coming out as queer.
The poem has energy, created by a combination of line breaks and caesurae which are used to build up rhythm: “your mother’s/ anger is like the sun, which is like love,/ which is the easiest thing – even on the hardest of days”. The use of italics is significant, another voice (the mother’s or the speaker’s words to her mother?) briefly breaking in. The poem also has movement, which is not physical or geographical, but emotional.
There is generosity in Chan’s poem, in which the mother’s anger is like the sun, but then becomes like love, a shift of metaphorical register from something positive, to something ambiguous (the sun can be scary as well as brilliant) and then into something positive again.
Your challenge:
Re-read and explore Chan’s poem, particularly the use of line breaks and caesura to build rhythm and evoke emotion, and the three-word movement: “anger is like the sun, which is like love”.
Now write a poem in the first person that begins with “Once in a lifetime”.
Think of a similar three-word movement (anger/sun/love) and develop it in your poem. It can be about a real situation in your past or current life, or something that happened to someone you know, or an imagined situation.
Leave yourself time to refine your draft and then follow the usual instructions:
- Write a poem in response to the challenge.
- Enter a link directly to your poem and your name by clicking Mr Linky below.
- There you will find links to other poets, and more will join, so check back for their poems.
- Read and comment on other poets’ work – we all come here to have our poems appreciated.
- Please link back to dVerse from your site/blog.
- Mister Linky will close on Saturday at 3 p.m. EST.
- Comment and participate in our discussion below, if you like. We are a friendly bunch of poets.
- Have fun.
Welcome to the dVerse Poets pub, lovely poets, and queue up at the bar for drinks and snacks. I look forward to reading your once in a lifetime poems.
Pingback: Hope for the Fatalist – PoetryPix
Love this prompt, Kim, especially your discussion of Chan’s poem and the 3-word movement. Fuel for the imagination!
I’d love a slice of lemon pie and espresso, if you have it. Will be back later to read some “Once in a lifetimes”!
I’m delighted you love the prompt, Dora, Lemon pie and espresso coming up!
This was quite a challenge, but thinking about the 3 word movement and that start made it work into something new…
Yes, that’s how started – and then went back to the title.
Pingback: Downstream – The Tigress Awakens
Hi Kim! It’s an intriguing prompt. I going to try to write to it.
I look forward to reading your poem, Merril.
😊
Hi, Kim!👋🏻 Thanks for hosting. I’ll have just a cup of coffee with cream.☕️
Hi Melissa! Are you surviving the summer? Coffee and cream on its way!
Great poem Kim and challenge and track triple whammy 🙌
I’m delighted you like it. I love Talking Heads.
Yes they are brilliant 🤩
Tina Weymouth’s bouncy bass!
Pingback: In A Blind Alley – The Author Stew webpage – Stories & Poems
Pingback: Enjoy the Violence | A Poem About Abuse and Speaking Up
Love this prompt. The poem is lovely and haunting all at the same time.
Thank you, Dawn. I’m delighted you like it.
I more than like it. I’ve been working on a piece for a few weeks and this prompt was the muse needed to bring it all together. Now it’s being moved out of draft folder. I’m excited at how it’s forming. So I’ll take a cup of camomile tea to stay zen, please.
Camomile tea and zen on their way, Dawn, and I look forward to reading your poem.
Hello, Kim. Great prompt!
Good morning, Jay! I’m glad you like it|!
Pingback: Once in a lifetime – Creative Experiments and More
An excellent prompt that got the little grey cells working. Thank you!
Oh, those little grey cells!
Pingback: You, Yourself and You – a poem by Paul Vincent Cannon | parallax
I so love your prompt Kim and the background resource, Chan’s poem is so moving, many thanks.
Thank you, Paul. I’m delighted you like it.
Pingback: Glow of Being – Yesterday and today: Merril's historical musings
A great and intriguing prompt, Kim. I will see what I can shake out of the cobwebs in my brain.
Thank you, Sherry. I look forward to reading it.
That is a dynamite poem!
Thanks Shay!
Pingback: Fading Away – 21st August 2026 – 1994ever
Thanks, Kim. I appreciate the prompt and lovely poem share. All new to me. Gave it my best shot… will be reading as many as I can. again, thanks. blessings to all. Selma.
https://selmamartin.com/poetics-once-in-a-lifetime/
I’ll be over to read shortly, Selma!
A wonderful prompt! I enjoyed the poem very much, too.
https://alittlebitofeverythingwithlove.com/2026/08/19/perfection/
I’m pleased you liked the prompt, Lisa!
I was struck by the phrase “anger is like the sun, which is like love” – it sounded like something intended to be deep and meaningful, yet was actually rather abstract and strained.
I asked the Google AI gods : “Isthis phrase is typical of an LLM trying to write poetry: ‘anger is like the sun, which is like love’.”
The answer was very interesting:
Yes, this phrase is highly typical of an AI or Large Language Model (LLM) trying to write poetry.
While humans can certainly write this way, the structure and logic of the line strongly mirror the patterns found in AI-generated creative writing for several specific reasons:
1. Circular and Abstract Logic
I asked Claude the same question and got an even more detailed explanation of how AI loves this kind of thing. Of course it does – it learned how to do it from humans.