Today, I’d like to spend a few moments speaking about “Voice” in poetry. I’m sure most of us have had the experience of reading a poem and recognizing the poet without seeing the byline or credit. When Luke Prater and his team had his critique site, they held several contests for participants. Entries were, of course, submitted anonymously. But I remember reading one of Claudia’s poems and having not the least doubt to whom it could be attributed. Claudia—and numerous other poets who participate in dVerse offerings—write work that just screams Here I am; it’s me! Poets of times present and past are recognizable in this manner: Gerard Manley Hopkins, William Shakespeare, Langston Hughes, Wallace Stevens, e.e. Cummings and (my own personal favorite) Mary Oliver to mention but a few.
As I understand it, voice or tone is what reveals the poets personal attitude about his or her subject. Extrapolate this idea, if you will, to other art media such as the visual arts or music. Van Gogh’s personal angst bleeds into his choice of subject, color and broad brush strokes that sometimes appear as though they were applied to the canvas in a passionate frenzy. Picasso’s need to deconstruct reality contributed to the importance of cubism in the first half of the 20th century. Visual artists turn to color, contrast, shape, perspective and other elements and principles of art to produce the effect that they are going for, to convey their moods and communicate their messages. So, too, do poets.
What are some of the tools available to those of us who write poetry to help us express our voice?
• Titles. Right away we can give the reader an idea of the theme we want to address by our choice of title.
• Alteration of sentence structure. Short sentences hurry the reader through the poem implying a sense of urgency. Longer sentences, in contrast, slow, lull, relax, induce reflection. Line breaks may or may not correspond with sentence length. (Refer to a previous article on enjambment.)
• Repetition. Repetition creates insistence as though the poet is saying Look, look, look! Don’t miss this!
• Rhythm, meter. Consider the formality of a Shakespearean sonnet juxtaposed to Eliot’s free verse. Which lends itself to a romantic poem? Which to social narrative?
• Sentiment. Some poets turn to effusive feeling, risking an almost-maudlin effect, while others create an intense emotional response, maintaining an almost chilling indifference. Take a moment if you like and compare Browning’s Sonnet 43 to Hardy’s The Convergence of the Twain.
Sonnet 43, Elizabeth Barrett Browning
How do I love thee? Let me count the ways.
I love thee to the depth and breadth and height
My soul can reach, when feeling out of sight
For the ends of Being and ideal Grace.
I love thee to the level of everyday’s
Most quiet need, by sun and candle-light.
I love thee freely, as men strive for Right;
I love thee purely, as they turn from Praise.
I love thee with the passion put to use
In my old griefs, and with my childhood’s faith.
I love thee with a love I seemed to lose
With my lost saints!—I love thee with the breath,
Smiles, tears, of all my life!—and, if God choose,
I shall but love thee better after death.
Public Domain
The Convergence of the Twain
BY THOMAS HARDY
(Lines on the loss of the “Titanic”)
I
In a solitude of the sea
Deep from human vanity,
And the Pride of Life that planned her, stilly couches she.
II
Steel chambers, late the pyres
Of her salamandrine fires,
Cold currents thrid, and turn to rhythmic tidal lyres.
III
Over the mirrors meant
To glass the opulent
The sea-worm crawls — grotesque, slimed, dumb, indifferent.
IV
Jewels in joy designed
To ravish the sensuous mind
Lie lightless, all their sparkles bleared and black and blind.
V
Dim moon-eyed fishes near
Gaze at the gilded gear
And query: “What does this vain gloriousness down here?” …
VI
Well: while was fashioning
This creature of cleaving wing,
The Immanent Will that stirs and urges everything
VII
Prepared a sinister mate
For her — so gaily great —
A Shape of Ice, for the time far and dissociate.
VIII
And as the smart ship grew
In stature, grace, and hue,
In shadowy silent distance grew the Iceberg too.
IX
Alien they seemed to be;
No mortal eye could see
The intimate welding of their later history,
X
Or sign that they were bent
By paths coincident
On being anon twin halves of one august event,
XI
Till the Spinner of the Years
Said “Now!” And each one hears,
And consummation comes, and jars two hemispheres.
Imagine a reflection on the tragedy of the Titanic in terms of the marriage of the iceberg and the ship without any consideration of the lives lost! This creates a chilling effect that disturbs us. Hardy thrusts the reader into the stark reality of death without a mention of the word. No sentimentality here.
There is one additional point I’d like to make about voice—the importance of writing to our passion. I’m sure we all recognize in our own work the difference when we write of subject that inflames us compared to those about which we feel more neutral. This can be a risk when responding to prompts although, don’t misread this—I believe the exercise and discipline of writing “assigned” poetry is a valuable tool in developing our skills. For example, I’m not enamored of certain types of form poetry. The sonnets I’ve written aren’t going to win a National Poetry Award BUT writing sonnets has helped me become more comfortable with iambic pentameter and I love the challenge of a Sestina that does call for that meter.
Today, I’d like to share a poem written by Jamie Dedes, a poet who stops by dVerse on occasion. Her poem, Haunting, is a magnificent example of writing to your passion, using the tools available that help create voice. Take a few minutes on your own to analyze the skill she shows in expressing outrage without effusion. Try to identify the emotion, the passion that underlies this example.
Haunting
When I die, don’t build a monument to me. Don’t bestow me degrees from great universities. Just clothe the naked. Say that I tried to house the homeless. Let people say that I tried to feed the hungry.”
Martin Luther King, Jr. (1929 – 1958), American clergyman, activist, role model, and leader of the American Civil Rights Movement
i tell you, you know nothing of despair
of hopeless grief and the dialect of
anguish, cry when you can tell me
you’ve lived in the side of Korea that
mandates smiles and orders you to
be passionless as you watch the farmer
dead and dead and dead, shot ninety
times in the head, the poet says*, and i
believe him, cry when you can tell me
that your door is not a barrier against
the warped passions of the puppet
marble-eyed, pathological, when a good
night would resound with silence not
gun shots, and the only dreams a child
has are of food and water everyday and
the safety of parents’ arms long gone
i tell you, i’m not sorry i can’t sympathize
with your complaints, the kitchen you
can’t afford to finish, the spouse that
died after thirty years of loyalty and love,
of children who fail to please you, when
you could count the blessing of a child
grown and healthy and not stolen into
war at eight or starved by five, spare me
the details of your latest diet or how your
new manicurist disappointed you or your
Scrooge of an employer who won’t give
you a raise this year, your complaints
are a cough into the wind while theirs
hang heavy on my heart, haunting me
and would it surprise you if, between the
vapid and whiners, power brokers and killers
this mother earth revolted, throwing us into the
original chaos of her first great experiment,
like a writer tossing out her first draft,
like a prototype that doesn’t work . . .
scrap it and begin again
The poet referenced is Jang Gil-su, a North Korean poet who defected.
© 2013, poem, Jamie Dedes, All rights reserved
If you visit Jamie’s blog, you will notice that she does not accept comments. She told me that this is so she can concentrate on her writing. You will not be disappointed…her strategy seems to work well.
For today’s prompt, I’d invite you to take a few moments to think about your own passions—what is it that most inspires, excites, outrages, motivates you. Write a poem in which you let your convictions, your issues bleed onto the canvas of your keyboard. Allow your voice to thunder forth.
To participate:
• Write your poem, post it on your blog or website;
• Copy the direct URL to your post and paste in the space that Mr. Linky (at the bottom of this post) offers you, along with your name or the name of your blog;
• Come back to the pub, leave a comment if you like, and take the time to visit and comment on as many of the other poets as you are able;
• Enjoy the process.
For dVerse Poets, I’m Victoria Slotto, preparing to leave the summer-like clime (It’s already in the 100’s here—Fahrenheit, that is) of the California desert to return home and enjoy spring once again. See you on the road.
Welcome all to the pub. I look forward to “hearing” what you have to say. Enjoy your stay here and don’t forget to sip some poetry and “toast” your fellow writers.
Wonderful poetry you share Victoria. Sharing my passion and what inspires me came easily.. and I continue to share haibun with you,
I love haibun–reading and writing.
This is such a wonderful article, Victoria. I did write about something I feel very strongly about…
Looking forward to reading it, Laurie.
this is a cool prompt victoria…yeah…let those voices be heard poets…smiles…and i remember that you told me you recognized my voice..it’s a bit like the hand-writing of a person maybe…so individual and i think it’s just naturally individual, we don’t have to really do something to develop it.. it just happens and maybe gets more and more characteristic with the years..
Your voice has always stood out for me, Claudia.
Thanks for hosting Victoria. Inspiration. Motivation. It’s nature that in her wide variety of guises that does it for me. I continue to find new facets that inspire me. Cheers!
And I enjoyed my little trip into Wales.
Way to go, Victoria! I wrote and posted one this morning, and I don’t think anyone will argue whether or not I have a voice (several of them) and the poem is definitely written using one of them. Hope y’all enjoy it!
You know, Charles, I hadn’t thought of it, but I have a few differing voices, too. Some light, some dark. Hmmm…multiple personality disorder?
You said it! We’re schitzoets.
hahaha i love your label for us charles…smiles.
🙂
Great article and prompt, Victoria. I am having an active day with granddaughter and later on my grandson; but hope to have time to write tonight. I was really moved by the poem YOU shared. See you later, hopefully.
Looking forward to it. Have fun with your grandchildren!
great article victoria…enjoyed the poetry you chose to share and the development of voice is def important…will be interesting to see where everyone’s apssions lie as well…still got a bit to get the kids out of the room for the day….but will be around here in a bit…
No doubt as to where yours lie, Brian. And, like Claudia, a most distinct voice.
passions…..ack! spelling in a hurry…smiles…
Thanks for the really great intro, Victoria. On the subject of voice, I sometimes wonder whether I have found my voice yet. I’ve not been seriously writing poetry for all that long, so perhaps I’m still searching for it. On the other hand, maybe I’m too close to the subject to be able to discern the distinguishing marks of my poems and other people would be far better qualified to point them out. And, then again, maybe if I knew what “my voice” is, I’d focus too much on being true to it and end up being false instead.
Don’t you think voice evolves throughout life, as we do? My “young” poetry was so maudlin.
Yes, I do think voice evolves over time, and it doesn’t always improve. Interestingly, the last post on my blog before I fell ill last year was on the subject of voice. It’s here http://rumoursofrhyme.wordpress.com/2012/04/11/rumours-of-water-by-l-l-barkat-part-2-voice/ for anyone who might be interested.
It is also possible to have more than one natural voice. Having been raised in a British Army family, I have a bit of a chameleon voice; I can blend into many parts of the UK by mimicing – often unconsciously – the local accent. I suspect this is possible in writing, although it would be more difficult to do.
i think that mimicry is often a way we learn…if you think we do as a child…how we learn to speak in the first place is still relatively unknown…but we o pick up on the language around us…i do think it is a part of the process…funny, when i first started writing poetry 3-4 years back…i had not read poetry in year…like 18 years…so i had a lot of catching up to do…smiles.
Having lived in many parts of the USA I found I pick up the varying accents, too. Interesting thoughts.
I wish, I wish, I’d had the benefit of reading your wonderful intro before writing my poem: I wrote it after reading your poem for the prompt which arrived early in my inbox. I waited and waited, but the dVerse prompt didn’t come up until almost my bedtime, so I posted my poem anyway.
But you wrote it so well, Viv. Hope you have a good night’s sleep.
Do I have one voice or many? Underneath it all, isn’t my preoccupation healing my heart and then the broken bones of public education in the USA? Yet, I have never been so happy. And then, too, to have such prompts as this to ponder! Thank you, Victoria and dVerse Poets.
As I said earlier, I really believe we all have varying and evolving voices.
Terrific post and I love the prompt! I’m posting a poem which reflects several of my current passions!Magician Thank you!
Off to read it soon. Should be fun.
I have no idea what my voice sounds like. I’m going to post the poem I write this morning because I think it fits the prompt. Maybe just the most passion I can muster today.
Our passions wax and wane, don’t they?
(I have left my manners in my other pants.) Wonderful prompt today, Victoria. It scares me a little. Thanks!
wait! you mean we have to wear pants!!!!
smiles. just kidding…ha….i think you spoke to a passion…or spoke your heart at least…
Reblogged this on pop-up-poetry and commented:
There’s always more to learn, and I’ve found this online community a very supportive way to do so. I don’t drop by regularly, but when I do, I’m always enlightened. Thank you, d’Verse and Victoria Slotto, for taking me here today. In response, I’m posting a new poem which I hope is beginning to speak in my voice.
Common to man
Song singer, spring bringer
flit, fly, cling to backyard feeders
find seed you prefer, spit out what
you don’t, the ground beneath you
a field of sprouted grain
come July. Splash in the garden bath
sing across the lawn, nest in hedge
and evergreen, delight me with
your winged life, your skied freedom.
Chickadee, house sparrow, jaunty white crown,
bright lined heads like laundered shirt collars stiff
with starch. The flash and strut of wide eyed males
yellow warbler, purple finch on tree top soap box, sing
choose me, choose me, I’m a builder, I’m a lifer,
count on me, me, me, me, me.
Females wearing drab observe, coy Mona Lisa’s
hear his unsung coda ringing in their ears;
the feathered flurry, nest of eggs, long sit,
hungry mouthed chicks, fledging and flights
scarcity, long dark nights
April’s you you you you you
frozen
in December air.
Love the lilt in this.
I have absolutely no idea how it came to be here… I believe I know just enough about technology to get myself in trouble. Sorry, Victoria… you can delete this comment if you like.
Beautifully set-out topic for your post today, Victoria.
And such a timely one for me personally. An aspect of poetry writing I had not consciously considered before.
Thank you, Aprille
Cool post, Victoria – wonderful poems. I am just exhausted and don’t think I can participate, but thanks much for giving me something to reflect upon. k.
noticed your last poem came down…i hope all is well k…
That was unintentional! But it is a sign of my current fatigue, I think. I’m just a bit worn out really, on several fronts. Thanks so much for your consideration. k.
It’s so important to take care of you, Karin! Feel better.
read the first 18 entries..now backing out…having a terrible headache…ugh..need some sleep…will be back in the am…smiles
Schlaf gut, Claudia.
rest up poet…sweet dreams.
Feel better in the morning, my friend.
* My Voice *
Excellent prompt! I have to say that threw me for a loop, Victoria.
Poetically speaking, it changes with the character of the particular write. Even when I write about myself, it is reflective of the mood I wish to convey at the moment. But is that *my voice*. Even free-style I doubt anyone could pick my words apart from among so many others.
I then chose to go through my words about me and see what I could hear. Turns out though I do a lot of verbal yelling with a voice that carries, it seems my writing voice is considerably sedate in comparison. Who knew?
There is a lot to think about re: voice. I agree, the subject drives it. But many of us revert to characteristic syntax, favorite words. Often very subtle little cues. Others are more obvious. Very unique to each of us.
Time to sleep here; I need to be wide awake tomorrow morning for leading the Grassmarket Community Project’s new Creative Writing group.
What? I’ve told you about that several times before? Really? Oh well … NIght all….
smiles
have fun at the community project man…look forward to hearing all about it…
Thanks Brian. I did have fun. If you really want to hear about it – try here http://rumoursofrhyme.wordpress.com/2013/05/03/behind-the-red-door/
You will fly, Tony.
Will be back in a bit…was great to see so many of the first 20 or so poets out and about commenting on each others work…that is def encouraging….keep it up…
Cool article, Victoria.
Voice seems to be a multiple factored thing of writer’s style, subject and tone tendencies. It’s taken me years to discover my own. I still can’t say if it’s consistent but it is clearer to me than when I first started writing. I guess I’m still learning, thus still easily influenced and desire to emulate those I admire. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn’t, all in all, it’s building up one’s own, discovering what I really want to say or show when I’m presenting a subject.
In some of the other comments, we’ve discussed how voice evolves over a lifetime. And how it can change depending on the subject.
Bravo! Well done, Victoria. I think voice may be about the most important thing we can learn … once we find ours, everything else will follow. An excellent post. Thanks for including me.
This is no big deal – somehow in translation a word was lost, the stanza breaks are gone, and the italics are gone. The thing is, it’s made me take another look at the way I broke up the poem. !!! I will have to rework it a bit a think.
Thanks for including me in this adventure.
Be well and poem on.
Jamie
Whoops. Sorry about the line break and italics. I cut and pasted but should have double checked. It still is an amazing poem, Jamie, and I thank you for allowing us to share it.
alright poets, my turn to find the bed…have a great evening and i will see you in teh morning…
sleep well bri..
good morning…back and catching up…
Hope you feel better today!
Enjoyed reading what you have to say about “voice” in poetry. Certainly it seems like one’s persona does shine through their writing, depending on experience. I’m still finding my poetic voice. Glad to contribute and join in with readers tonight and tomorrow.
Enjoy!
Wonderful prompt Victoria! making one’s voice heard is a challenge!
Thank you, Akila.
good morning…had fun reading through the overnights with my coffee…good stuff…will stop back in through the day…enjoy poets!
Nice blog!!! This is my first time here. I am putting my voice for the plight of street children. It is really heartening to see them languish on roads, with no guidance and care.
So happy to have you here, Vandana. We hope to see more of you.
G’morning all. I’m going to sneak in a last round of golf this morning before leaving for home. Will be back to catch up right after. I’m enjoying your voices!
swing away….
I’m hoping the my dry wordless months are past and some poetry will come to me!!…looking forward to reading those in the pub today!!
just another little thought….I taught in Belfast in the school where all the dads worked at the famous docks that built the titanic….just remembered!!
wow..this is very cool geraldine…
So glad you added that piece of info about the docks, Geraldine. The world is so small.
Thank you for the interesting voice prompt and poems. Some voices are easily identified but only a few I think. I am not sure which category I fall into . I think only others can determine that. Enjoyed this one anyway. Thanks!
Thank you, Cressida!
I have enjoyed reading these contributions, thanks for a great prompt.