Samuel Peralta here!
A couple of Open Link Nights ago, I linked to a poem of mine called “The Treachery of Dreams”, a poem published in the online literary journal Metazen. It’s a fairly long poem, at nine stanzas, and half of it is in French, so many readers might have ignored it. The first two stanzas go like this:
Ceci n’est pas une – This is not a poem.
Still green, the apple contemplates the man.
Le fils de l’homme, il contemple la pomme.
Les hommes en chapeaux fall like summer rain.
Still green, the apple contemplates the man.
The artist paints a portrait of an egg.
Les hommes en chapeaux fall like summer rain.
Across a grove of leaves, a rider’s fled.
The first line is a riff on Rene Magritte’s famous painting of a pipe with the words “Ceci n’est pas une pipe” – “This is not a pipe”. And as you progress through my poem, you fill find that each and every line is a description of yet another of Magritte’s surrealistic works of art, with a line-repetition scheme – you can see it in the excerpt above – that emphasized the surrealistic nature of the images, as in a dream.
In the comments of that OLN event, I noted that my offering would be “Treachery of Dreams”, and I added “Hint, hint”. Why? Because it hinted that my next Form For All article – this one – would be all about the poetic form I used, the pantoum.
The pantoum is a fifteenth-century Malaysian form, which started out as a folk poem, made up of rhyming couplets. This changed as the pantoum spread in popularity, especially with French and British writers of the nineteenth-century, including Victor Hugo and Charles Baudelaire. The twentieth century has also seen a resurgence, with John Ashbery, Donald Justice and Wendy Cope producing notable examples.
As the pantoum spread, its folk poem format changed. Modern pantoums are of any length, composed of four-line stanzas where the second and fourth lines of each stanza serve as the first and third lines of the next stanza, until the final verse.
In other words, the pantoum is a type of structured verse made up of cycling refrains, a line that is repeated. Each verse is a quatrain, either unrhymed or rhymed ABAB.
Let’s go through this step by step. The first verse sets up the initial pattern of four lines.
The second verse uses the second and fourth lines from the first verse as its first and third lines. The second and fourth lines of the second verse are new lines.
The third verse uses the second and fourth lines from the second verse as its first and third lines. The second and fourth lines of the third verse are new lines.
And so on, for as many verses as the poet can handle, until you reach the final verse.
This final verse uses the second and fourth lines of the preceding verse as its first and third lines, as per the usual pattern, but for its second and fourth lines it uses the first and third lines of the first verse, reversed.
Thus, the first line of the entire poem becomes its last line, a circular denouement.
The beauty is that, if done well, the pantoum results in a poem where the structure beautifully emphasizes the themes and images by repetition.
It’s easier when you see examples.
The first pantoum I’d ever written was published in the book “Goodbye, Billie Jean: The Meaning of Michael Jackson”, edited by Lorette Luzajic, a collection of essays, short stories, and poems in memoriam. Here it is:
Moonwalk
A story about Neverland
He’s quiet as his mother reads
His sisters cry, his brothers stand
From in the dark, his father pleads
He’s quiet as his mother reads
The words begin to form a song
From in the dark, his father pleads
He asks if he could dance along
The words begin to form a song
The melody begins to burn
He asks if he could dance along
He rises, makes a single turn
The melody begins to burn
He’s walking backwards, not a glance
He rises, makes a single turn
He’s crucified the lord of dance
He’s walking backwards, not a glance
Afraid to stop, afraid of joy
He’s crucified the lord of dance
In the mirror he sees the boy
Afraid to stop, afraid of joy
His world is broken, out of place
In the mirror he sees the boy
Up close he finds he has his face
His world is broken, out of place
From in the dark, his father pleads
Up close he finds he has his face
He’s quiet as his mother reads
From in the dark, his father pleads
His sisters cry, his brothers stand
He’s quiet as his mother reads
A story about Neverland
—–
The challenge gets more difficult (or more fun) the more stanzas you write. In my opinion, the minimum, to get the right effect, is three stanzas.
So… Can you do a 3-verse pantoum, or better? I’m eager to see!
As usual, share your poem via the link button below, and please, visit your fellow writers to see what they’ve come up with. I know I’m looking forward to it!
—–
Samuel Peralta – on Twitter as @Semaphore – is the author of Sonata Vampirica; Sonnets from the Labrador; How More Beautiful You Are; and Tango Desolado, all of which hit #1 on the Amazon Kindle List of Hot New Releases in Poetry on their debut.
Copyright (c) Samuel Peralta. All rights reserved.
Images public domain / via WikiMedia Commons.
Interesting information, Sam! I’ve always enjoyed the Pantoum form, even though it is definitely QUITE a challenge. Thanks for hosting.
Hi Mary, glad you could stop by! Yes, it is a challenging form, but I find that once you get the first couple of refrains, it starts to write itself.
Hi Sam,
Your pantoums are just great – I especially like the French one with al the magritte. The translation works well for the form. I’ve done a few in the past and some explanations on my blog and one commenter (a mathematician named David Feldman) made this very nice graphic for a rhyming Pantoum showing the repetition of the lines:
A1 B1 A2 B2
……B1 A3 B2 A4
…… …A3 B3 A4 B4
…….……..B3 A5 B4 A6
…….……. … A5 B5 A6 B6
…….…….…….….B5 A2 B6 A1
With the As the rhymes and the numbered lines the actual lines as they are repeated.
I don’t know if that is useful, but I thought it very clever of him. I’ve posted a couple before so I’m going to see if I can come up with something new. I hope the alignment of that above doesn’t get messed up when I click “post comment” done here. k.
k…where were you with that when i was writing mine? smiles…
Ha! I can’t wait to look at yours. Hopefully will give me some spunk to do a new one!
This is one of those poems which I actually think is more effective when the rules are bent a bit! (Not to say that Sam’s aren’t great not breaking rules.) k.
sam slays form…
Or bites into it! k.
Does the apple contemplate the man, or the man contemplate the apple? 😉
I usually break the form by writing to the form and then doing the bending in the first edit.
K, that is a really good mathematical graphic for the Pantoum! I will steal it for my next poetry lecture, thanks!
oy…i remember this one from before…pantoum is quite the challenge…like a dance to learn the steps forward and back…in my usual style i made it my own bit…smiles…nice one sam…
Yes, I posted “Treachery of Dreams” before, but my Michael Jackson one is new to dVerse (albeit published elsewhere). It’ll be good to see everyone’s work, I’ll get out there right after dinner!
This is one of those forms that take time so I might get round to responding with a new poem in some weeks time. So I’ve reposted from one stop days. It was done two years ago!
…and i still remembered it…
I haven’t seen that one yet, looking forward to getting on the trail tonight, thanks for joining in, John!
Tricky, tricksy form–fun!
ha yes it is…i went into it confident…adn after about 4 pages in hte notebook reworking i finally got one to work…smiles…
It is tricky, isn’t it, Susan? But fun!
sam….you had me shock frozen when you first told me that you’re going to do pantoums..but i gave it a try… smiles.. thanks for a wonderful article….
I’m glad you gave it a try, Claudia… Pantoums look very intimidating, but the great thing about them is that the repeated lines mean that when you write two lines, you’ve actually written four!
Thanks for hosting this form, Samuel. I’m fond of the pantoum –it has bit more room than some other repeating forms, and allowing for a bit of fudging, the poet can really do some amazing tricks with it. Your Magritte inspired one is just excellent, and the French melds beautifully and also adds variety even when repeated somehow. I’ve written a few–I’ll link one later if nothing new comes up.
Thanks for joining in, I do like the French thrown in, it created opportunities for new meanings as well as fun rhymes between two languages. Looking forward to what you come up with…
Sorry not to be able to come up with a new one in time, Sam—got one started but it just will not straighten up and rhyme right!—I will maybe do it for OLN next week if I can get it beaten into submission–and my old ones had all been posted on dVerse previously, and not really that long ago. But I still love that you did this prompt, and the examples of it I’ve been able to get to have been fascinating.
Sam, I love the pantoum form, and really enjoyed your Michael Jackson poem. I don’t have time today to write a new pantoum, but I’ve written a few before and found one that I had never linked here at dVerse. Now I’m off to read some poetry with my lunch. Peace, Linda
reading some poetry with the lunch sounds not bad at all…
Linda… so glad you could join me on this one, it’s one of my favourite forms to do. Hope lunch was greate!
linking an old pantoum that I wrote….love this form. I haven’t been around for awhile at Dverse. It’s good to be back. I am working on getting my muse back. It has been reluctant to show itself lately.
ja, ja…the muse is a fickle thing…smiles…great having you back seek the sun…enjoyed your pantoum as well..
hey its good to see you…and a great one to bring back…you def set the mood in your piece…
My muse is named Anastasia Steele, and I use handcuffs to keep her from wandering away.
Just kidding! Yes, I understand how tough it is sometimes to write. I had a long drought at one time, it lasted years. Never again, I hope.
haha…you had me there for a second sam…smiles…
Hi Sam, as you know Pantoum is one of my favorite forms. I’ve written several. I will try to find a new one before the doors close … I think nearly everyone has read the ones I’ve previously posted. I did like the one I did on Stein Picasso..it was somewhat novel. I’ll see what I can do. Thanks for the excellent article and especially loved the Michael Jackson poem. Very cool the way you worked in both his joy and pathos.
I’ve only read a few of your Pantoums, Gay, so anything you offer will be like a discovery to me. Looking forward to it!
Thanks for the challenging prompt!
Thanks for stopping by Laurie, I hope you give it a try, if not today then sometime soon!
Mine is also an old one, but I don’t seem to have posted it on my blog, so maybe it’ll be new to you. They take me ages to write, and I’m too tired to start tonight. I’m looking forward to reading all the pantoums, expecting some fun – I could do with a smile.
My pantoums aren’t brand-new either, I just Swiffered them before inviting you in 🙂
grabbing lauries and then will be back after football practice!
nice…have fun…
was…but oh so hot…smiles…sleep well…
ok poets..on my way to bed…will be back in the morning.. have fun, writing..and reading…smiles
‘Night Claudia, see you in the morning!
samuel, i am deluged with time deadlines for a second novel before needing to return to full or very-full time work 😉 but just needed to tell you what a treat of an idea your prompt is; had read claudia’s and got a whiff of how much fun it could be; so anyway, best wishes, hope to read some of ya’ll’s creations 😉 thanks!
Cheers, and so glad you could stop by… Glad you enjoyed the prompt, and good luck with the novel!
very much appreciate it samuel, thank you 😉
Hey Sam! Awesome form and I LOVED your Michael piece! So much so, I used it as my guide…hope that’s okay?
So happy you could join, Tash! Will be over right after dinner!
Thanks for another challenging form, Sam.
As this is my first time to try this form, I would appreciate your feedback. Happy day to everyone ~
Very happy for you to join up, I’ll be by in a moment!
Thanks for the instruction, Sam…had not tried this form before. I loved your Michael Jackson poem…sad…thanks for sharing that. I’ll be back after dinner to make visits.
Glad you liked the poem, and for dropping by tonight… I’m just starting my visits 🙂
Absolutely appreciate the stretch and challenge to explore a new form. A late posting on a long week, but it’s good to be among poetry friends!
Hi Sam – so out of train/car/trip, and did a rather grim one, of sorts. k.
That was definitely a very serious pantoum… turned me pensive for a while. But well done.
Thanks.
Okay I gave it a shot though it twisted me up a bit.
haha it is twisty…but you did great with it Kristina…this can def be an intimidating form…
The pantoum form does turn you into a pretzel, doesn’t it?
I’ll be back with a poem,
I ran out of time while reminiscing. Imagine!
Thank you, Sam, for the clear essay and brilliant examples
you did a great job with it susan…and i love the message in your poem…smiles…
Thanks for joining in, Susan, great work!
Writing this was fun! It was a puzzle. But it was fun. Thank you for the challenge!
▌ AWE ▐
It’s a puzzle and a challenge, but I find that after three stanzas, it begins to write itself!
Hi. I did it, and found it to be like pick-stitching, adjusting, twisting. Pretty cool.
What a great comparison! Yes, it is kind of like pick-stitching, now that you mention it, isn’t it?
good morning poets! fell asleep watching a movie last night and never made it back…looking forward to seeing what you have written…be around shortly…
Good morning all! It’s been a wonderful visit to everyone so far, and I’m looking forward to see if there’s anything else that comes this way. Keep writing!
Cheeky enough to add an old one, actually. Only ever done two of these (after last year’s pantoum challenge here). Haven’t written much of anything lately, but perhaps this will get me going! Thanks for a lovely prompt, and as always for being here!
It looked great from here, CC! When I find that I’m stuck for writing, I set myself a challenge of a theme and a form, and it usually jump-starts the creative fuse.
Excellent write up Sam. I’ve always loved reading this form, yet to my shock, I’ve done little composition of my own, a handful in notebooks, but only one posted to my site previously. Perhaps I’ll now rework some of those in the notebooks, but the one I’ve linked up here, is freshly penned this morning. Can’t wait to dig into everyone’s work. Thanks again.
I’m sure there are more diamonds in your notebooks than you know! Time to riffle through the pages to find another rough gem that you can hew away at and form into something brilliant.
What a great prompt Sam, and a big thank you from me for introducing me to the Pantoum.
Polly, I’m so glad you joined us here, and I do hope to be able to catch more of your poems in the future!
made it back finally…spent a nice evening with friends, sitting in the garden, chatting, glass of wine… will read those that came through the door while i was away and then off to bed…
The glass of wine sounds good… think I’ll go and get myself one!
Another one to drag me out of my comfortable formless zone. Mine’s clunky and bent all out of shape, but I tried.
Thank you so much for this post. I’ve never written a pantoum and I had a lot of fun trying. I plan to work with this form some more. It took me a bit longer to complete the poem but I am glad to get it done in time. I learned much from this attempt and your article.
smiles…catching the last couple myself….family movie this evening…swiss family robinson and ice cream sundaes….everyone tucked in and off to read myself…smiles.
Just finished the last of the contributions myself… ah, if only I had more time to read poetry! Anyway, a long weekend stretches ahead of me, and I’m preparing to stretch out and enjoy it. Cheers!
I was out and about other business and missed this prompt, but wanted to express my awe and appreciation at the depth of your prompts, Samuel. Your pantoum about Michael Jackson is beyond-stirring&beautiful. I just hope that his family has read it……
hey lydia! happy saturday! sorry you missed the prompt….
we do have Poetics coming up today at 3 pm…and anyone that wants a head start….we are looking at History….smiles.
History, eh? Thanks for the tip, Brian!
Lydia, thanks so much for stopping by and reading, and thanks for your kind words about “Moonwalk”.
I wrote it right after Jackson’s death, so it’s not a new poem… and you never know who might have read it…
But it does express a lot of the thoughts and feelings I personally had at the time, at the passing of someone who – with all his faults and indiscretions and imperfections – was undeniably one of the greatest artists of his generation.
I wanted to thank everyone who stopped by, everyone who left a poem, and especially everyone who visited another poet to read their work and leave some thoughts or small form of encouragement…. That’s what keeps poetry alive, what keeps this community alive… Thank you!
And, speaking of tips… an extra for those courageous few still reading these comments…
I’m up again for Forms For All about a month from now, and the subject for that day might just possibly be blank verse sonnets. Maybe. Just possibly.
Cheers all! 🙂
Samuel~ just posted by Poetics poem, and did it in Pantoum form. What a wonderful exercise. I love the form!
Will try to read as many Pantoums as I can this weekend…