Tags
Samuel Peralta here…
About a month ago, my article for Form for All, “Poetry as Semaphore“, posed the challenge of using Twitter – with verses containing at most 140 characters – in poetry.
In that piece, I included a verse as follows:
A Saint-Saëns concerto, La Muse et le Poète.
Over the mother-of-pearl inlay on the cello,
your fingers decipher the sphinx’ second riddle.
The Sphinx – if you didn’t know it – was a legendary creature, one with the body of a lion and the head of a human being.
The image of the Sphinx has been immortalized on the expanse of the Egyptian landscape – its lion body fashioned in stone, its human head adorned as a pharaoh.
In Greek tradition, there was only one Sphinx, a merciless entity with the body of a lion, the wings of an eagle, and a woman’s face.
According to tradition, she was the daughter of monsters – some say of Echidna and Typhon, or Orthus and Echidna.
Whatever her ancestry, the Sphinx of ancient Greece sat on a rocky ledge near the city of Thebes.
There, she posed – to all who sought passage – what is perhaps the most famous riddle in history:
What is that which in the morning goes upon four feet
upon two feet in the afternoon,
and in the evening upon three?
Those unable to answer she tore apart and devoured.
Most passersby chose to make their way around this merciless obstacle.
The riddle was solved by Oedipus, who answered: Man—who crawls on all fours as an infant, walks on two feet as an adult, and then must use a cane in old age.
Upon hearing the correct answer, the Sphinx is said to have cried out in despair, and dashed herself upon the rocks below.
Apart from the use of riddles in classical texts, riddles have a strong foundation in Old English poetry.
The tradition is based on an Anglo-Latin literary tradition whose principal exponent was Aldhelm, the Abbot of Malmesbury Abbey, Bishop of Sherborne, and a Latin poet and scholar.
One of his most celebrated works was Enigmata, a collection of 100 metrical riddles, included in his Epistola ad Acircium as a treatise on poetic meter.
Aldhelm was inspired by the Latin poet Symphosius, who in the 4th or 5th century collected his works in the Aenigmata, a collection of 100 Latin riddles written in tercets of hexameters.
Riddles thus can trace an imposing literary ancestry, although contemporary puzzles now known by the name of “riddle” obscures this fact.
In another set of Twitter poems I composed, Riddles with Fruits, I attempted to revive the the tradition of the riddle, and bring it into a more contemporary literary framework.
For example:
Riddles with Fruits – 1
Naranjita, I strip away your
navel-blush veneer of zest and peel;
your pithy heart falls apart,
yields to me a citrus kiss.
The answer to this riddle, also a possible title: Orange.
Often a riddle poem can be written by thinking of an object (the title), composing the poem as describing the object, and then dropping the title.
You can think of the riddle technique as an unnamed or hidden metaphor – the answer to the riddle being, of course, the metaphor.
Of course, the craft is in balancing the poem so that the answer is not too obvious but not too difficult either.
The reader needs both the intrigue of having to think through the poem, and the aha! moment of discovery and realization.
The poetic riddle, as I have it, is a subtle transformation of T.S. Eliot’s objective correlative – the encapsulation in a symbol or object of a particular emotional response or state of being.
See if you can find the answer – the hidden metaphor – to this one:
Riddles with Fruits – 2
Sunday afternoon’s best savoured
like a ripened fruit, halved, scored,
turned inside-out into an exquisite,
aromatic sun.
Which brings us to the Sphinx’ second riddle.
Some ancient accounts report that – had you been able to answer the Sphinx’ first riddle correctly – you would have been given a second riddle:
There are two sisters:
One gives birth to the other,
And the other, in turn, gives birth to the first.
The answer, which would presumably lead to the ultimate triumph of the traveler: Night and day.
This brings us to the third, and greatest, riddle of the Sphinx:
If Oedipus answered the first riddle correctly, and the Sphinx then took her own life, how did the Ancients know what the second riddle was?
—–
Tonight, I am inviting you to write your own poetic riddles.
We’re looking for a short verse – of any structural type, but as brief as a non-literary puzzler (think of “St. Ives”, as a maximum – or keep to 140 characters if you like a challenge), which poses a riddle to be guessed.
The object, the title of the verse, is the answer to the riddle.
Or leave out the object, if you want your reader to guess the answer (as I did).
Post the whole poem on your blog and and link to it here, so that others can come and visit your poetry journal.
And by the way, the answer to Riddles with Fruits – 2, above, is: Mango.
Samuel Peralta – on Twitter as @Semaphore – is the award-winning author of five titles in The Semaphore Collection – Sonata Vampirica, Sonnets from the Labrador, How More Beautiful You Are, Tango Desolado and War and Ablution – all Amazon Kindle top five best sellers in poetry. The Semaphore | Art & Craft newsletter shares useful observations on writing, giveaways, and book news.
Copyright (c) Samuel Peralta. All rights reserved.
Images public domain / via WikiMedia Commons or as attributed.
Wow, Sam. So much to learn in this (I’m woefully under-educated in the realm of mythology. Thank you for hosting. Time factors compelled me to post an old poem. Hope it’s not too far off.
Hi Victoria, great to see you here, so glad you could raise a glass!
Awesome informational article, Semaphore. I’ve been away from the computer all day, but will try to get something written and posted tonight… unless I get too riddled with confusion. = )
riddle me this
riddle me that
smiles..
hiya laurie…
Hi. I just don’t know it I’m up to it tonight. It’s been such a long, arduous day… will try tomorrow morning when I’m fresh (that’s my most productive time).
I had a similar day yesterday, I’m just catching up right now…. a work hangover alas.
ha. a work hangover…yeah i hear you on that one some days…smiles.
Laurie, it’ll be wonderful to see what you do. Catch you later!
I loved this… your fruit riddles were exquisite. and got an idea that turned into 5 stanzas. It’s fairly simple to get all of them once you get one…. and the answers is in the comment.
I think all of the stanzas can be a tweet…
another thing I thought of was the riddles of Bilbo and Gollum, which I think are consistent with the old Anglo-Saxon tradition.
my initial thought was of the LOTR riddle as well….
Bjorn, thanks for the kind words!
I did have a draft of this article which referenced the LOTR scenes, and another draft which was based on “Tom Riddle” from Harry Potter, but in the end I went with the Sphinx.
wow – that is an awesome article…love the sphinx riddles and i loved, loved, loved your fruit riddles sam – i like how this makes us look at everyday things in a different way and challenges us to find new words to describe something that it is not too obvious… IMHO a fantastic poetic exercise… let’s get those muscles stretched wide…smiles
happy thursay….
Claudia, thanks! Yes, it makes for a great poetic exercise, a little bit like the Martian poetry exercise that I put together a while back, don’t you think?
Yes, I guessed the correct answer. Will try to come back later with my own riddling poem…
cool. hope to see you. smiles.
Good for you, guessing the right answer! Will catch you later as well!
Totally fun challenge, and I resisted my Tolkien riddle loving nature to try a few that are a bit different,.
Thanks for stopping by, and for trying something different… but there’s no need to resist Tolkien! I don’t!
Excellent informative post Sam – thank you. Hope my little effort fits the bill – not certain that it does…
Anna :o]
Hi Anna, I’m sure you’ll hit the mark! Thanks so much for keeping me company!
Great information. Thank you Sam. Not sure if my entry qualifies as a riddle, but I tried anyway.
eh, you are def ok…the fun is in the trying…mine is not so great other, but hey…smiles.
Myrna, I’m sure yours qualified! Thanks for raising the glass!
Interesting. Sphinx is a mysterious mythic figure which has been used time and again in literature.
I wrote something… but something is a little big. I just got into the flow of it, forgetting the character limit. The answer to my riddle is quite concrete. I have never been good in solving riddles or in devising one.
And the answer to your unanswered riddle… does it have anything to do with eggs!? Yes, now you know, I am not good at it. 🙂
The character limit isn’t too important, but that people be able to remember it and repeat it (like a riddle puzzle). Still, go with the flow! I can’t wait to see your piece!
P.S. The answer to Riddle 2 above is in the article itself, near the end. It was a trick to make people keep reading. 🙂
Always look forward to reading your articles, Sam – educational and entertaining too… and I love the exercise you’ve given us here – what fun!
fun, educational and entertaining…what more could we ask for… i agree… thanks sam
With Sam at the helm, we sail into the deepest & darkest waters without fear, for his knowledge is our mantle & Muse; too often I feel like an ill-educated ersatz poet, but it is never too late to pick up new information while hanging around the dVerse Pub.
Nothing about you is ersatz, Glenn!
Hi Ruth, thanks so much for the kind words – educational and entertaining is what I aim to be!
Exquisite task, Sam.
Wonderful post to go with it.
I didn’t manage to make it light-hearted. More Eliot than elegant.
Will try to do better tomorrow.
so you’re promising us a second poem..? smiles
Once I’ve seen what every body else is making of this task 🙂
Did someone say she was putting together a second poem? 😉
Aprille, Mr. Eiot would be proud! Thanks for stopping by to raise a glass!
just getting from getting the kids out of here and playing catch up….dude, def a challenge to think on…esp after reading your fruit ones….heh, def could have turned to bilbo’s riddle but i tried my hand at my own a bit….
I’m sure yours will always be uniquely you, Brian…
back in a bit…we’re practicing a sketch for my husband’s brother’s wedding saturday…
video….just saying….ha
oy…better not… was a bit chaotic…smiles… we still have another day to practice..smiles
Well, sounds like a wonderful family celebration… congratulations to the couple and all!
time for me to go to that place that has feathers but can’t fly, wrinkles all over but never uses anti aging creme…now what could that be…?
smiles
see you in the AM…
LOL! Cool valediction, Claudia!
Poetry – it’s rarely easy! Thanks, Sam.
I did two prompts tonight – I will be back here tomorrow to visit and comment. Again, thanks for this very interesting challenge!
Hi Margaret, poetry is rarely easy, but it’s worth it! Looking forward to seeing you on the trail!
Thank you for another challenging post Sam ~ It took me some time to get my head around the requirements but I finally saw the light, smiles ~
Happy day to all ~
Ah, so wonderful to see you here, Grace! Will be stopping by your place later on today…
Wonderful post! Thank you for sharing with us the fruits of your knowledge 🙂 ~Jason
so you writing something jason?
Perhaps…likely…most assuredly tardy 🙂
Okay…I’m IN ….
booyah!
Hey Jason, good to see you here and thanks for the kind words!
Gosh, Sam, the response for your prompt is a bit shy of overwhelming–not that you give a tinker’s damn about numbers–but I am a bit surprised; thought the brave poets out there in the dVerse galaxy would jump on this one. I wrote my typically longish poem as forensic riddle, but have been enjoying those who wrote short stanzas, individual riddles as well. Nice choice of form, sir. One day you might tackle the form I helped to create, “Cinemagenic”, where the verse takes the form of a complete screenplay; and more than that, a complete film of the mind.
I’m never really worried, Glenn, it’s always quality that comes first! But good to see you here, and your epic effort always makes up for the numbers! 😉
“Cinemagenic”…. hmmm… you never know, sounds intriguing…
Sam, I lenjoyed your essay above and your examples. I tried, but have come up with less than poetry, much more a Pre-K version of “Wait, Wait–Don’t tell Me.” And I had fun doing it, though I had hoped a more lyrical song would arise as usual with your inspiration. Have a great weekend.
Susan, this hybrid of riddle and poetry is always tough to balance – you should see my draft work! – but I’m sure you found a balance. Looking forward to seeing it!
Love this!
Thanks Jessica, and cheers!
This was fun Sam. Great article. I made my riddles easy because when I read the others I could not work out the answers to any of them. That could just be me of course!
Easy riddles are always welcome – as long as I have that aha! moment. Wonderful to see you here!
I thought I posted this but here is my second try…
I really like your brilliant riddles Sam! You are right..it is not easy to write these, giving the poem the tone of a riddle….so I think I might earn a “C” for my effort….considering the lovely examples of the legend of the Sphinx you presented to us..
ha. def think i missed the tone of the riddle, for sure…
good to see you ma’am…smiles.
So happy to see you here! Effort always gets an “A” from me 🙂 I agree it is a tricky balance, and it comes with writing a lot of them. Thanks for the kind words!
got my riddling on 🙂 and in 140 characters too!
oh my…used to write 160s on sundays and it is not easy…
Booyah! You did it all!
Oh, this is a great post, and a terrific challenge! I wish I’d seen it earlier as I’m about to go to bed. I see that Mr. Linky still has 23 hours to go, though. Maybe I’ll try tomorrow!
yep you have until midnite tonight so you still have around 18 hours….
Linda – never too late… and if you miss Mr. Linky, please link it in the comments, eventually I or someone else will see it!
iNTERESTING! I hope mine is riddled enough! smiles…fun friday all… ll come back on sat morn to visit and catch up! meanwhilei am still having issues in laptop commenting on wordpress pages. wonder why?!?
Good to see you here, I’m sure yours will be riddlin’ good!
Sam, much as I love you, this post makes my brain hurt! The aphasia has not entirely disappeared, making of the simplest writing task an Everest-sized challenge!
Awww, thanks, Viv, that’s so nice of you… but sorry about the brain-popping (what riddles are supposed to do, anyway). You take care of yourself, I’m just happy you dropped by to say hi. 🙂
I had to pull an overnighter for my day job, and now I have to actually go in…. oh, if only you cold make a living writing poetry!
Anyway, I see there have been a few stalwart souls trying out this challenge. Brian and Claudia, thanks for keeping my seat warm!
I will get to every one of you, so stay tuned!
Finally joining the party. Hope there is still some mead left. What a fun prompt, Sam, thank you.
Saved some mead for you, Marya! Glad you could make it!
Hi Sam – very cool prompt. I have a couple but was only able to work on one. Isn’t it too bad one cannot make a living on poetry! At least not most. k.
Thanks, glad you were able to drop by! I’m happy with one, but you could always reserve the other for a rainy day. 🙂
Thanks for challenge! Wish to have more time for poems…
Hi Irene, me too! Good to see you here, though.
Cutting it fine : 24 hrs is not enough to get my brain in gear these days.
I totally agree! But this is what Mr. Linky gives us… if you ever missed the deadline, you could always post that link in the comments and someone will stumble over it sooner or later…
Thirty-nine poets have joined in so far, with still time to go… this is amazing!
Forty-one entries in, with one coming just under the wire. Whew! I had such an amazing time guessing everything here… beautifully done, everyone!
Until next time… I hope you enjoy the rest of the summer… and keep writing!
Wow! You’av just murder a part of my naivity with this! Getting tutored!
In my opinion, the answer to #2 is similar to “harmony”. It is possible that our sense of the balances between time and space are inadequate to that of the Sphinx. Perhaps Oedipus saw a glimpse of this in her death and orating symbolism filled in the rest for future perceivers.
I have been working on a riddle….
I cover you both night and say. At times I would stay away. After the heat I will come around, you may see me, but I don’t make a sound. What am I?